Wednesday, April 17, 2024

Can India feed the world?

Last week, Indian PM Narendra Modi told U.S. President Joe Biden that India was ready to ship food to the rest of the world following supply shocks and rising prices due to the war in Ukraine.

Modi said India had “enough food” for its 1.4 billion people, and it was “ready to supply food stocks to the world from tomorrow” if the World Trade Organization (WTO) allowed, the BBC reports.

Commodity prices were already at a 10-year high before the war in Ukraine because of global harvest issues. They have leapt after the war and are at their highest since 1990, according to the UN Food and Agricultural Organisation (UNFAO) food-price index.

Russia and Ukraine are two of the world’s major wheat exporters and account for about a third of global annual wheat sales. The two countries also account for 55% of the global annual sunflower oil exports, and 17% of exports of maize and barley. Together, they were expected to export 14 million tonnes of wheat and over 16 million tonnes of maize this year, according to UNFAO.

“The supply disruptions and threat of embargo facing Russia means that these exports have to be taken out of the equation. India could step in to export more, especially when it has enough stocks of wheat,” says Upali Galketi Aratchilage, a Rome-based economist at UNFAO.

India is the second biggest producer of rice and wheat in the world. As of early April, it had 74 million tonnes of the two staples in stock. Of this, 21 million tonnes have been kept for its strategic reserve and the Public Distribution System (PDS), which gives more than 700 million poor people access to cheap food.

India is also one of the cheapest global suppliers of wheat and rice: it is exporting rice to nearly 150 countries and wheat to 68. It exported some 7 million tonnes of wheat in 2020-2021. Traders, reacting to rising demand in the international market, have entered contracts for exports of more than 3 million tonnes of wheat from April to July, according to officials. Farm exports exceeded a record $50 billion in 2021-22.

India has the capacity to export 22 million tonnes of rice and 16 million tonnes of wheat in this fiscal year, according to Ashok Gulati, a professor of agriculture at the Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations. “If the WTO allows government stocks to be exported, it can be even higher. This will help cool the global prices and reduce the burden of importing countries around the world,” he says.

There are some reservations though. “We have enough stocks at the moment. But there are some concerns, and we should not become gung-ho about feeding the world,” says Harish Damodaran, a senior fellow at the Centre for Policy Research, a Delhi-based think-tank.

First, there are fears of a less-than-expected harvest. India’s new wheat season is under way and officials project a record 111 million tonnes will be harvested – the sixth bumper crop in a row.

But some experts are not convinced. Damodaran predicts the yield will be much lower because of fertilizer shortages and the vagaries of the weather – excessive rains and severe early summer heat. “We are overestimating the production,” he says. “We will know in another 10 days.”

Another question mark, say experts, is over fertilizers, a basic component of farming. India’s stocks have fallen low amid the war; India imports di-ammonium phosphate and fertilizers containing nitrogen, phosphate, sulphur, and potash. Russia and Belarus account for 40% of the world’s potash exports. Globally, fertilizer prices are already high due to soaring gas prices.

A shortage of fertilizers could easily hit production in the next harvest season. One way to get around this, says Damodaran, is for India to explore “wheat-for-fertilizer deals” with regions such as Egypt and Africa.

Also, if the war gets prolonged, India might face logistical challenges in stepping up exports. “Exporting huge volumes of cereals involves huge infrastructure like transportation, storage, ships. Also the capacity to start shipping in high volumes,” says Aratchilage. There is also the question of higher freight costs.

Last, there is the overriding concern over rising food prices at home – food inflation hit a 16-month-high of 7.68% in March. This has been mainly driven by price jumps of edible oils, vegetables, cereals, milk, meat, and fish. India’s central bank has warned about “elevated global price pressures in key food items” leading to “high uncertainty” over inflation.

The Russian invasion is likely to have “serious consequences” for global food security, according to think-tank IFPRI. The UNFAO estimates that a prolonged disruption to exports of wheat, fertilizer and other commodities from Russia and Ukraine could push up the number of undernourished people in the world from eight to 13 million.

By the government’s own admission, more than three million children remain undernourished in India despite bountiful crops and ample food stocks. (Prime Minister Modi’s native state Gujarat has the third highest number of such children.) “You cannot be cavalier about food security. You cannot play around with the food earmarked for the subsidized food system,” says Damodaran.

If there is one thing India’s politicians know it is that food – or the lack of it – determines their fate: state and federal governments have tumbled in the past because of soaring onion prices.

BIG Media
BIG Media
Our focus is on facts, accurate data, and logical interpretation. Our only agenda is the truth.

BIG Wrap

Prosecutors push election angle in Trump ‘hush money’ case

(Al Jazeera Media Network) It is a blockbuster legal case, set to dominate headlines for weeks to come. On Monday, Donald Trump has become the...

Iran attack ‘will be met with response,’ says Israeli army chief

(BBC News) Israel has vowed to respond to Iran's attack on Saturday and is considering its next steps, the country's army chief says. Tehran launched...