Friday, May 24, 2024

“New Zealand Prime Minister Calls for a Global Censorship System”

New Zealand Prime Minister Calls for a Global Censorship System

jonathanturley

C-Span screengrab

New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern is the latest liberal leader to call for an international alliance to censor speech. Unsatisfied with the unprecedented corporate censorship of social media companies, leaders like Hillary Clinton have turned from private censorship to good old-fashioned state censorship. Speech regulation has become an article of faith on the left. Ardern used her speech this week to the United Nations General Assembly to call for censorship on a global scale.

Ardern lashed out at “disinformation” and called for a global coalition to control speech. After nodding toward free speech, she proceeded to lay out a plan for its demise through government regulation:
But what if that lie, told repeatedly, and across many platforms, prompts, inspires, or motivates others to take up arms. To threaten the security of others. To turn a blind eye to atrocities, or worse, to become complicit in them. What then?

This is no longer a hypothetical. The weapons of war have changed, they are upon us and require the same level of action and activity that we put into the weapons of old.

We recognized the threats that the old weapons created. We came together as communities to minimize these threats. We created international rules, norms and expectations. We never saw that as a threat to our individual liberties – rather, it was a preservation of them. The same must apply now as we take on these new challenges.

Ardern noted how extremists use speech to spread lies without noting that non-extremists use the same free speech to counter such views.   To answer her question on “how do you tackle climate change if people do not believe it exists” is that you convince people using the same free speech.  Instead, Ardern appears to want to silence those who have doubts.

While referring to a global censorship coalition as a “light-touch approach to disinformation,” Ardern revealed how sweeping such a system would likely be. She defended the need for such global censorship on having to combat those who question climate change and the need to stop “hateful and dangerous rhetoric and ideology.”

“After all, how do you successfully end a war if people are led to believe the reason for its existence is not only legal but noble? How do you tackle climate change if people do not believe it exists? How do you ensure the human rights of others are upheld, when they are subjected to hateful and dangerous rhetoric and ideology?”

That is the same rationale used by authoritarian countries like China, Iran, and Russia to censor dissidents, minority groups, and political rivals.  What is “hateful” and “dangerous” is a fluid concept that government have historically used to silence critics or dissenters.

Ardern is the smiling face of the new generation of censors. At least the old generation of censors like the Iranians do not pretend to support free speech and openly admit that they are crushing dissent. The point is that we need to be equally on guard when censorship is pushed from the left with the best of motivations and the worst of means.

As the great civil libertarian Justice Louis Brandeis once said, “the greatest dangers to liberty lurk in insidious encroachment by men of zeal, well-meaning but without understanding.”

United Nations
2.54M subscribers
🇳🇿 New Zealand – Prime Minister Addresses UN General Debate, 77th Session (English) | #UNGA

https://jonathanturley-org.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/jonathanturley.org/2022/09/25/new-zealand-prime-minister-calls-for-global-censorship-system/amp/

 
 

Stephen Heins
Stephen Heins
My Story So, here is my story, I have no earthy college degrees, a couple of French courses short. I have been a very good golfer, basketball player, small town boy, six time winner of greased pig contest, big city man, businessman, interstate highway drifter, high and low plains America adventurer, self-indulgent, distant father, auto-didactic, Ivy Leaguer, scholar, student, lost soul, historian, art historian, musicologist, poet, poetry aficionado, business writer, economist, “Blizzard of One” broadband “David” to high speed Internet “Goliaths,” Internet Open Access champion, practical environmentalist, energy efficiency expert, member of Chicago Climate Exchange, 3-times matrimony loser, lobbyist, technology theorist, Bakken Basin podcaster, energy practical, political advocate pain in the ass and all around gadfly simply… because I was self-appointed. It's so much easier, now that I confessed. Steve Heins
spot_img

BIG Wrap

Putin’s military purge echoes Prigozhin’s call to act

(BBC News) When one top defence official is arrested in Russia, that is interesting.   When five senior defence figures are handcuffed in less than a...

‘Strong punishment’ – China initiates military drills around Taiwan

(Al Jazeera Media Network) China has started military drills surrounding the self-governing island of Taiwan, according to Chinese state media. The state-run Xinhua news agency...